Best Mattress Toppers in Canada: Top 5 Picks and Buyer’s Guide

Everything You Need to Know About the Types of Mattress Toppers

When browsing through Canadian mattress toppers, you will come across a variety of types (which can make it hard for some shoppers to reach the final decision). And each of them has its peculiar properties. Will they work for you? That’s what we are about to find out. So, here’s what we are dealing with:

• Memory foam. It’s the most popular option these days, and there are many reasons for that. Memory foam can deliver unparalleled pressure relief thanks to its cradling abilities. It’s also a good solution for partnered sleep, as foam effectively absorbs shock from motion and allows couples to remain undisturbed during the night. Finally, memory foam is rather affordable and widely available. However, you need to remember that this material is likely to trap heat (unless it’s specially treated – infused with gel, for example). Additionally, some users find foam restricting, which means it’s not ideal for combo sleepers or sex (1). 
• Polyfoam. Polyfoam is slightly more resilient than memory foam, so it shouldn’t restrict movement just as much. Typically, polyfoam is much cheaper. However, it does not provide such pinpoint support that memory foam does. Plus, polyfoam tends to be less durable.  
• Latex. Latex toppers (whether natural or synthetic) are quite bouncy and respond fast to applied pressure. A good latex topper can make a memory foam mattress slightly less restricting. Additionally, latex sleeps neutral and tends to be very durable. It gets better: because this material is rather molding, it can offer decent pressure relief without that quicksand feeling. The deal-breaker is the price, however. Latex mattress toppers are among the most expensive models, which can be an issue for some shoppers.
• Wool. A good wool topper can make your mattress feel cozier and softer. Wool is very breathable, so it’s not likely to make you sleep hot (2). At the same time, this material is a good insulator, so a wool mattress topper can keep you warm during winter. Such toppers do require extra care when it comes to cleaning, but some users disregard this aspect to enjoy the coziness a wool topper can provide.
• Fiber-filled. Usually, these toppers are meant to resemble down or feathers. They are airy, squishy, and soft. Such toppers are also cheaper than most other options and would be a good choice if you want to make your mattress slightly softer for a reasonable price. However, with time, fibers lose their springiness, and such toppers can become flat.
• Feather. A good option for those users who ordered a mattress in a box and didn’t quite guess the needed firmness level, a feather topper can make your slightly stiff bed comfier and much softer. Naturally, down and feather toppers are pricier. They may also require special care when it comes to maintenance (3). And let’s not forget that some people are allergic to this material. These flaws aside, feather and down topper can add a luxurious feel to your bed, which is certainly worth the money.

A quick note: don’t mix up mattress toppers with pads and mattress protectors. Toppers are usually thicker and can alter the feel of the mattress. Pads aren’t as thick and work to add an extra layer for a moderate comfort improvement. Don’t expect your mattress to feel different with a pad – the changes will be quite small. As for mattress protectors, those serve to keep dirt, dust, and moisture away from your bed. Mattress protectors are usually the thinnest ones and don’t offer any comfort enhancements. 

Also read: How Long Does A Mattress Last?

Best King Size Mattresses in Canada

How to Pick the Best Mattress Topper in Canada: Your Sleeping Position

A good mattress topper is the one that can provide enough support and the needed amount of cradling for you.

And how much support and cushioning you may need will depend on your preferred sleeping position:

• Side sleepers. When lying on your side, the protruding body parts can develop painful pressure points. Therefore, side sleepers require a generous amount of cushioning and should pick thicker, softer mattress toppers. A 4-inch model should be ideal in this case if you are average-built. For heavier sleepers, it might be better to get an extra-thick model. 
• Back sleepers. This sleeper type does not require much cradling (just for the hips and buttocks). Therefore, a thinner mattress topper should suffice. Medium or medium-firm mattress toppers usually work the best for this sleeping position.
• Stomach sleepers. Stomach sleepers need reliable support to avoid any unhealthy curves in the spine. Therefore, firmer mattress toppers work better for this sleeping position. If you are a heavier sleeper (over 230 pounds), you can even try an extra-firm model for ultimate support. 
• Combination sleepers. If you are a combo sleeper, you probably need a topper that won’t restrict your movement when switching positions during sleep. In this case, you might want to go with a medium or a medium-firm topper. And it would be a good idea to avoid memory foam, as it’s quite enveloping.

How to Make the Right Choice: Buyer’s Guide

You know about the mattress topper types. And you probably have an idea what firmness level would be the most suitable for you. 

But what else should you consider?

After all, there is more to a good mattress topper than just its firmness.

Well, there are certain factors that demand your attention when shopping (and can potentially help you make the right choice). They include:

• Thickness. Some people think that thicker mattress toppers are more durable. However, durability depends on the material. And thickness will determine your comfort level. Generally, thicker toppers are usually softer and serve to provide extra cushioning. Thinner, firmer models are typically used to make soft mattresses feel sturdier. A quick note: you will find the widest thickness variety among memory foam and latex toppers. Other types don’t usually offer many thickness options.
• Temperature regulation. No one likes to sleep hot, right? That’s the common issue with memory foam (and sometimes down) toppers. If you don’t mind a slightly bouncier feel, get a latex topper that sleeps cool naturally. However, if you don’t want to give up that pleasant hug memory foam can offer, at least get a model that is infused with gel beads or has an open-cell structure. Many foam toppers also have small air channels all across the perimeter for increased breathability. 
• Fitting style. If your mattress topper slips off or moves during the night, it can cause sleep disturbances (and no one wants that, right?). So, you need to think about the proper fit. Most mattress toppers come with either elastic straps or an elastic skirt (kind of mimicking the fitted sheet). It’s better to avoid those models that simply go on top of your mattress without any “fastening system”.
• Off-gassing. Some odor is present in most memory foam (and sometimes a rubbery smell in latex) toppers upon arrival, which can be an issue for sensitive users. You might want to avoid these materials or simply prepare to leave your new topper in a well-ventilated room for a while before you start using it.
• Motion transfer. If your mattress is overly bouncy and it drives you or your partner crazy, a good motion-absorbing topper could become your savior. In this case, you might want to invest in a thicker memory foam topper. It will kind of counteract your bouncy mattress, which is great for undisturbed partnered sleep.
• Safety certifications. You are going to spend a lot of time lying on your mattress topper. Naturally, you probably don’t want it to contain any harmful chemicals that would emit dangerous odors right into your face. Look for such certifications as GreenGuard, CertiPUR-US, OekoTEX, Global Organic Textile Standards, etc. If you are looking for a down topper, the Responsible Down Standard (RDS) signifies that the ducks and geese received humane treatment.
• Warranty. For your protection as a customer, it’s better to choose toppers with extended warranties. The warranty coverage can also be a good indication of the product’s quality. The shorter the warranty is, the less sure you can be in your new mattress topper. Of course, durability may depend on many other factors, but the warranty coverage is a good place to start if you are looking for a reliable topper.
• Hypoallergenic materials. If you are prone to allergies, make sure the mattress topper you choose was specially treated to reduce (or prevent) the allergen build-up. Also, it might be a good idea to get a model with a removable cover. This way, you will easily get rid of dead skin cells, moisture, dust, and other bits that might be accumulating in your bed.
• Density. As a rule of thumb, denser mattress toppers are more durable. Additionally, if we’re talking about foam or latex models, denser options often have stronger edges and thus, can provide a more uniform support across the surface. At the same time, a denser topper material could mean reduced airflow. As a result, such mattress toppers may sleep a bit warmer.

F.A.Q.

How long do mattress toppers last?

Mattress toppers usually last for around 2-3 years. However, the durability may depend on many factors. For instance, latex and high-density memory foam toppers don’t lose their properties that fast. Additionally, softer toppers tend to deteriorate faster than firmer models.

How much does a mattress topper cost?

On average, mattress toppers vary from $130 to $450.

Do mattress toppers really work?

Yes, a good topper can make your mattress feel more comfortable. It might also extend the lifespan of your bed. However, if the mattress is too old and can’t support your body properly anymore, a topper might not be able to save it or alter its feel.

Which mattress topper thickness should I pick?

If your mattress feels too stiff and you want more padding, you can get a 3- or a 4-inch topper for extra cushioning. If you need to make a soft mattress feel firmer, a 2-inch topper should suffice (however, make sure that it’s firm and dense).

What is the best mattress topper for back pain?

Usually, memory foam and latex toppers are the most effective when it comes to back pain. Foam and latex have the ability to conform to one’s body curves, which may aid proper weight distribution, minimization of pressure points, and pain alleviation.

Wrapping Up

A mattress topper is not a miracle that can magically save your old, saggy mattress.

Still, a good topper can significantly change the way your mattress feels and, consequently, make you sleep more comfortably.

Whether you choose memory foam, latex, or any other type, make sure you pick the proper thickness and firmness for your favorite sleeping position. It also won’t hurt to check the safety certifications. And of course, don’t forget to read more about the warranty coverage to ensure your protection as a customer.

Nevertheless, if you would want our recommendation, you should definitely check out the Puffy mattress topper. The Puffy mattress topper is our absolute favorite because we could not find something that could count as a flaw to this mattress topper. It adjusts to the body shape and helps people with back pain. People with different sleep types and sleep preferences will find this mattress topper a great addition to their bedroom because they get the chance to adjust the firmness that they want from it. If you want something flawless just like us, you will love the Puffy mattress topper.

What do you expect from your new topper? Do you need to make your mattress softer or more supportive? Let us know in the comments section!

References:

1. Nadia-Elysse Harris (May 10, 2013). Your Memory Foam Mattress Could Be To Blame For Your Bad Sex Life. Retrieved from https://www.medicaldaily.com/your-memory-foam-mattress-could-be-blame-your-bad-sex-life-245758 
2. Rebecca Knight (June 19, 2020). Can’t sleep this summer? Wool bedding could be the answer to a good nights sleep. Retrieved from https://www.idealhome.co.uk/news/woolroom-wool-bedding-2-250806
3. Karen B. Gibbs (March 12, 2019).  How to clean a mattress pad. Retrieved from https://www.today.com/series/how-often-should-you/how-often-you-should-clean-your-mattress-pad-right-way-t53736